Comments on: Engineering a vibrant Indian economy for the future http://indiblog.com/102/engineering-a-vibrant-indian-economy-for-the-future/ The Pride of India Sat, 31 Jul 2010 11:59:47 +0000 hourly 1 By: Sooraj http://indiblog.com/102/engineering-a-vibrant-indian-economy-for-the-future/comment-page-1/#comment-420 Sooraj Mon, 16 Jan 2006 18:21:27 +0000 http://www.indiblog.com/102/engineering-a-vibrant-indian-economy-for-the-future/#comment-420 Hi Prof. Barhat - There are quite a few articles on Reservations here yet you've commented on the subject on an unrelated page. Anyhow, I wonder if the poor person will still not go to the person of his own community rather than a stranger who might be better. But your thoughts against reservations and the prediction that this is bad for the country are made on firm ground. But isn't it surprising that the intellectuals have not risen against this irrational law in a more organized way? Hi Prof. Barhat – There are quite a few articles on Reservations here yet you’ve commented on the subject on an unrelated page.

Anyhow, I wonder if the poor person will still not go to the person of his own community rather than a stranger who might be better. But your thoughts against reservations and the prediction that this is bad for the country are made on firm ground. But isn’t it surprising that the intellectuals have not risen against this irrational law in a more organized way?

]]> By: Prof N. K. Barhat http://indiblog.com/102/engineering-a-vibrant-indian-economy-for-the-future/comment-page-1/#comment-415 Prof N. K. Barhat Mon, 16 Jan 2006 15:23:55 +0000 http://www.indiblog.com/102/engineering-a-vibrant-indian-economy-for-the-future/#comment-415 The reservation in India is affecting the quality of services and specially teaching and research. In the practice people never compromise with the quality. When a person is accused of a murder he will not go to a lawyer of his own caste he will contact the best lawer. Similarly when some one is seriously sick he will contact the best doctor and not the doctor of his own community or caste. when some is searching a teacher for the tution for his son or daughter he will contact the best teacher who had given the best result in the previous compition exams. Unfoutunatly in the government jobs the caste reservation is doing havoc. I have seen persons on such a high posts as the Directors of the National Research Institutes and the Professor who were not the worth for the first post in that cadre. Hence the government now wants the private institutes to follow the reservation so that the geneous of the county should suffer and the below average people should rule the country. With in a decade all the head of the Institutes and all the Directors of the government departments, all the Chief Engineers wiil be from the reserved castes only. Is it a justice? The reservation in India is affecting the quality of services and specially teaching and research. In the practice people never compromise with the quality. When a person is accused of a murder he will not go to a lawyer of his own caste he will contact the best lawer. Similarly when some one is seriously sick he will contact the best doctor and not the doctor of his own community or caste. when some is searching a teacher for the tution for his son or daughter he will contact the best teacher who had given the best result in the previous compition exams. Unfoutunatly in the government jobs the caste reservation is doing havoc. I have seen persons on such a high posts as the Directors of the National Research Institutes and the Professor who were not the worth for the first post in that cadre. Hence the government now wants the private institutes to follow the reservation so that the geneous of the county should suffer and the below average people should rule the country. With in a decade all the head of the Institutes and all the Directors of the government departments, all the Chief Engineers wiil be from the reserved castes only. Is it a justice?

]]>